Skip to main content

Posts

Featured

Why some Christians think transgender is gnostic—and why they’re wrong

This past summer the well-known New Testament scholar, N. T. Wright, made headlines for his letter to the London Times in which he claimed that “the confusion about gender identity is a modern and now internet-fuelled, form of the ancient philosophy of Gnosticism. The Gnostic, one who ‘knows’, has discovered the secret of ‘who I really am’, behind the deceptive outward appearance. . . . This involves denying the goodness, or even the ultimate reality, of the natural world.”

The claim that trans* identity is a form of gnosticism has a long legacy. Oliver O’Donovan may have been the first to connect them in his 1982 pamphlet Transsexualism and Christian Marriage, where he says the “claim to have a ‘real sex’, which may be at war with the sex of my body . . . [is] a kind of Gnostic withdrawal from material creation.”

The 2003 House of Bishops report, Some Issues in Human Sexuality: A Guide to the Debate, quotes O’Donovan directly to provide expert support for the view that “transsexualis…

Latest Posts

Imma Let You...Keep Talking

Breaking Silence: Amy’s Story

The God Who Saves: Reader Reviews #4

Journeying into Utter Darkness: Trinity Sunday Sermon

Why the Church Is Not in Exile: A Response to Brad East

Reading Rudolf Bultmann Forty Years Later

I See That I Am Blind: A Lenten Sermon

The God Who Saves: Still More Reader Reviews

Announcing the Society for Dialectical Theology

The God Who Saves: More Reader Reviews